Sam has posed some pretty tough questions to us in his last email. I'll do my best to respond to them as well as I can. I'm glad to share how I'm feeling about urban teaching right now, since I wish that I'd seen and heard more about it when I was at Smith. The truth of it is that you can't ever hear enough, or see enough. You can't really be prepared for it all -- for the kids, the problems, the administration, the parents, and the multitude of other factors that make up the job.
I came to Gerena with a strong conviction of wanting to teach in an urban school. I will admit that I doubted my ability to teach there and to relate to those kids. My worries have shifted a bit now. I worry now about how to service all the students in my class appropriately. Montessori is based on giving the child what she needs, and with 1/3 of my class on IEPs, and over a third on meds for ADHD, I am not able to give them each what they need. I just can't. It took a while for me to realize that and then to admit it freely. I rarely feel like I truly cannot do something -- I've made a life out of doing things that other people were fairly sure I could not accomplish. But without the appropriate support services in the classroom and out, I just can't do what is needed for my students. So I am left with simply doing my best, and hopefully that will be good enough this year. What else worries me? The administration in the building. Trying to marry Montessori with MA frameworks and expecting teachers to adhere fully to both. Finding time for my family.
How do I feel about my decision to teach at Gerena? Well, last Thursday I had a mini breakdown, having to do with working my second job and feeling overly stressed and more tired than I've ever been in my life. As my husband and I talked about ways to problem solve my sleep deprivation, he told me that he thinks I should apply for other jobs next September, preferably in Hatfield (our hometown). This is something that I have considered, although technically my contract with Springfield is for a few years still. I think about it, sure -- gee, wouldn't it be great to work in a town that [provided chart paper, had structures set up to support students in need, where students didn't bring weapons to school in fourth grade, where you could park outside safely, etc, etc, etc]. But when my husband said that, I was reminded just how committed to Gerena I am. (I also reminded my husband of this, telling him that his support in this was of great importance to me. He has promised never to mention quitting again.) I feel very strongly that I belong at Gerena right now and it is really becoming "my" school. I was surprised one day to realize I felt that way. I am invested in these students and this transition to Montessori and my own development as a teacher. Even though I cry on the way home from school sometimes, and wish like crazy that I could just go to bed at 9 just ONCE, I am so glad I came to Gerena. It has become my life in every way, and I am currently trying to pull back a bit from that, to retain some precious time for myself. That's been part of the learning curve for me. But I am learning, and I do believe that I will be really good at this job someday. I do feel like things will continue to improve with time.
What discourages me? Knowing that kids go home to not the greatest home lives, knowing my limitations in their lives, feeling pulled in several different curricular directions (Montessori, Responsive Classroom, district standards), not having enough help, never getting a sub when I am out, the lack of communication in the school, the disorganization, the complaining, and particularly the hesitation to take responsibility for anything. I read a quote lately that I want to pass out to everyone -- teachers, admin, students, etc. It's from Maya Angelou, and reads: "If you don't like something, change it. If you can't change it, change your attitude. Don't complain!"
I can imagine why people leave this job. It's so tough. It takes such a deep toll on you -- a physical one and a deep emotional one. You might leave for so many reasons. The teachers who I know are considering leaving are ones that don't believe that Montessori will work (proof positive that a cohesive vision for the school is needed). Often it's the teachers who are alone in the classroom, without a para or help of any sort. They don't feel supported or appreciated. Speaking of appreciation, no one can ever really understand how much time you put into your job. I myself feel like I can never quite leave it fully behind.
Things that encourage me, and sustain me: my Montessori mentors. I know so many teachers who would have already left if not for the amazing quality mentors at Gerena right now. Without them we all would be floundering. The students sustain me as well. How can I leave them? Finally, my faith in what is coming also sustains me, and that's something that might be specific to Gerena. I know what a normalized Montessori classroom looks and feels like, and I wish that for these Springfield kids. I believe we can get there. So it's partially that vision that sustains me as well.
This blog has also helped. Thanks to all of you for reading and sharing your thoughts and support.
To the NYC Chalkboard
Tuesday, December 4, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
5 comments:
Johanna,
I just wanted to say that your post was very moving and inspiring for me. It reminded me of the title "A Hope in the Unseen" because you're working towards a goal that others might not see at the moment. I really like how you maintain your faith and convication in what you are doing, despite so many obstacles and struggles. I am sure you are making a positive difference in these kids lives, even if you can't do everything for them. Keep up the good work!
-Jen
Hi Johanna,
Thank you so much for this post. Your comment about how people don't recognize all the work you and your fellow teachers do really struck me, because I think that's one of the fundamental flaws in our society--we do not recognize the tremendously important work that is teaching. I hope you know that you are admired and appreciated among the people who read this blog. I hope your vision for Gerena and Montessori can be realized. Your students are lucky to have a teacher like you.
best,
Lauren
Hi Johanna,
This post made me think so much about the experiences I have had teaching and working in all sorts of classrooms. In my student teaching this year - there are only 17 students in my class but of those 17 students 2 are emotionally unstable, 3 are on meds for adhd, 5 are ELL students, one student was new to our class just last week, one has been back and forth between homeless shelters and another student is partially blind in one eye and can barely read at all. Our days are never dull between emotional breakdowns, students dancing around the classroom and the last student I mentioned often resorts to kicking and hiding under desks because he knows he can't do what the other kids are doing. Although we have support for many of these children - it is clear that some students need more help than others and that a one to one is desperately needed. My teacher has been teaching for quite some time and she is at a loss this year. She says she goes home and just wonders why she can't help these kids, why she can't control them. I have to admit that there are days where I feel guilty too because of the way that my day went. Then the only thing that keeps me sane is thinking - what if these students didn't have teachers like myself or my cooperating teacher. The impact that we have on them - though it may not always be obvious is so crucial to their learning and their development as individuals. Thus, I feel for you as you describe your dedication and yet sense of hopelessness at times. I am sure that your students look up to you more than you may realize. Their lives at home are so tough and honestly none of us will ever understand exactly what they go through. We can only be there to support them even when they don't want it. I hope that you stick it out at Gerena because you seem passionate about the changes that could be made there. Keep your head up and know that we are all rooting for you!!!
Good luck-
Karen
Hi Johann,
I just want to thank you for sharing your honest and open opinions. Your job seems unbelievably tough, I have a lot of admiration for you. I'm sure your students, as well fellow teachers and the administration will appreciate your positive attitudes and your desire to stick with it. Keep up the good work!
Johanna, you are a beautiful beautiful person. I know that you realize that your students are beautiful, and that Gerena is a beautiful place, but I hope you also realize how beautiful YOU are. I love your posts, always, this one is no different.
A 2nd job? My goodness. I know it's not uncommon for teachers to have 2nd and 3rd jobs (I know I'll have to do the same with $75,000 of student loans on my back) but it INFURIATES me. I love working retail or food service jobs on the side because these jobs are places where if I work hard enough, everything gets DONE. It is different from teaching because I feel a sense of accomplishment and zen from mopping at the end of the night, knowing that I'm on the last step. Heck, doing something that has steps is just refreshing. But the fact that teachers, who work harder than most any other profession out there, often HAVE to work a 2nd or 3rd job, not want to but have to, makes me so unbelievably angry. You deserve so much and I am sorry, so very sorry that you are not getting what you deserve and need. It is just more of a testament to your character that you are surviving and thriving despite all this.
I only work in schools three days a week for afterschool programs, never more than 2 hours at a time and I already think about my kids ALL THE TIME. They are always there. I take my failures seriously -- less personally than I have in the past, but still, man, it hurts to know you could have done better. This is exhausting. It's thrilling, and it's WHAT I NEED AND WANT TO DO (just as I'm sure you feel about Gerena, you made that clear) but it's already so, so tiring and I know I have a lot more of this to look forward to. But that's okay, I know it will make me happy and if I'm lucky, just as beautiful and hopeful a teacher as you are.
Thank you!
- Janel Glinski '08
Post a Comment